Your Ideal Customer Profile Is Missing the Reason They Would Buy
Company size and job titles don’t explain a purchase. A worked example of rebuilding an ICP around the decision a buyer has to defend.

If your ideal customer profile says “operations directors at mid-sized manufacturers,” we’d want to know what prompted those directors to start looking for help. One may be dealing with another missed shipment, while another is planning next year’s maintenance. Their companies could match every field in your profile, but they’re unlikely to find the same message useful.
Company size and job title give you a place to begin. To write something the buyer recognizes, you also need to understand what they’re responsible for and what has changed in their work. That means looking at the purchase from inside the business, including the conversations your contact will have after the sales call ends.
We’ll use a fictional maintenance consultancy for packaging manufacturers to work through this. The company and the buying situations below are illustrative; a real consultancy would need to check the assumptions against its own customers.
Start with the work you can deliver
A useful profile would tell this consultancy which equipment it understands, where it can work and what maintenance resources the customer already has on site. Those details affect whether it can help. A plant with a capable internal team might need specialist advice on one recurring fault, whereas a plant with nobody available to act on the advice may need a service the consultancy doesn’t provide.
Industry, geography and company size still matter, particularly when they determine whether an account is within reach or can afford the work. We’d keep those boundaries, then add the conditions that make the service practical. If your recommendations depend on the customer having an engineer available to implement them, that belongs in the profile before it becomes a problem during delivery.
From there, we’d identify the people involved. The maintenance manager might investigate the fault and recommend outside help, while the operations director is responsible for the next production stoppage. Finance approves the expense, and the plant manager decides when an engineer can get access to the line. Knowing all four roles helps explain why an interested contact may still be unable to authorize the work.
An ideal customer profile describes the organizations you can serve well. Buyer personas describe the people involved, but they become more useful when you can explain how each person takes part in a real purchase (and who can stop it).
Reconstruct what made them look for help
In our example, the maintenance team has repaired the same machine several times. Production resumes after each repair, only for the fault to return. Following another late delivery, the operations director asks whether anyone understands the underlying cause.
That gives the consultancy a specific problem to discuss: investigating a recurring fault and establishing which maintenance changes are worth making. “Improve operational efficiency” could describe almost any service sold to the plant, so it offers little help when deciding what the website should say or what a salesperson should ask.
We’d also want to understand what happened during the last stoppage. Perhaps it delayed an order or created overtime; perhaps the repair used time reserved for other maintenance. Asking about that incident is more useful than assuming every plant experiences downtime in the same way, because the consequences help explain which recommendations the buyer will consider worthwhile.
There doesn’t have to be an emergency. The consultancy could be hired during routine planning, before a new production schedule leaves less time for repairs. Keep the reason to act separate from the question of whether the account is a good fit. A suitable company may have no need this month, while an urgent inquiry may concern equipment your team has never worked on.
Interactive figure: fit vs readiness
Understand the alternatives and the approval path
The buyer already has options. The maintenance manager could keep repairing the machine, ask the manufacturer for help or assign an internal engineer to investigate. Your consultancy has to make sense alongside those choices, so a comparison with competing consultancies covers only part of the decision.
The current approach also has advantages that are easy for a seller to overlook. The team knows what to do, nobody has to arrange a site visit, and there’s no unfamiliar fee to explain. An outside assessment may require access during production hours, which could make it difficult even for someone who wants your help.
If a buyer says they cannot take the line offline, we’d find out what access the assessment actually requires before writing a response. A shutdown they cannot accommodate is a delivery constraint, and a more persuasive script won’t remove it. The same conversation should establish who owns the budget, which approvals are needed and when the work could realistically happen.
Then consider what the person recommending you needs to defend that choice. The maintenance manager may want evidence of experience with the same equipment. The director may need a clear scope and a sample of the recommendations, while finance needs to understand the cost and what spending decision the assessment will inform. A row of client logos can leave all those questions unanswered, however impressive it looks.
Interactive figure: the decision they have to defend
Give the profile enough detail to change the copy
The consultancy’s starting profile might read: “Mid-sized packaging manufacturers. Operations directors and maintenance managers. Pain points: downtime and efficiency.” We’d develop that into something the team can use:
“Packaging manufacturers using equipment our engineers know well, within our service area, with an internal team able to carry out recommended maintenance changes. A relevant assignment is a recurring stoppage the team has repaired without establishing its cause. The maintenance manager evaluates our approach, and the operations director sponsors the assessment because of its effect on production commitments. We need to establish who approves the expense and when the plant can provide access. Immediate repair cover and guaranteed fault elimination fall outside this service.”
With those assumptions written down, the website has a clearer subject. “Maintenance consulting for operational excellence” could become “Investigate a production fault that keeps coming back.” The copy beneath it would explain the assessment and the access required, with a sample report showing what the customer receives. It would also make clear that an assessment cannot promise to eliminate every fault.
Outreach would follow the same thinking without pretending to know what is happening inside a prospect’s plant. “We investigate recurring faults on packaging lines. Is that something your maintenance team needs outside help with?” opens an honest conversation. Claiming that their facility is losing money to downtime would require evidence you may not have.
Once a prospect describes a problem, the next questions can become more specific: “Walk us through the last time this happened. What did the team do, and what remains unresolved?” Then, “If we identified a change to make, who would arrange and approve the work?” Their answers help you assess whether the service fits and what information is still missing.
Check the profile against decisions that actually happened
For a real engagement, we’d start with customer interviews and the records around completed purchases, then look at comparable prospects who declined or stalled. Asking someone to reconstruct events tends to reveal more than asking for a general reason they chose you. “Who did you speak to after our first meeting, and what did they ask?” can uncover the internal discussion your sales team never heard.
AI can help compare those interviews with proposals and follow-up emails, provided the material is authorized for that use. We review the patterns against the sources before deciding what they mean. A deal marked “lost on price,” for example, might have gone to a cheaper supplier, been postponed or failed to secure internal approval. Each calls for a different response.
One buyer’s concern is worth investigating, but we wouldn’t turn it into a defining feature of the market without looking for it in other comparable decisions. Keep confirmed details separate from interpretation, and revisit the profile when delivery exposes a poor fit or a new customer takes a different route to approval.
If your current profile gives you a list of companies but little idea how to approach them, email angelica@sirotinventures.com. At Sirotin Ventures, we use customer interviews, research and commercial analysis to understand those buying decisions, then carry what we learn into messaging your team can use.

Written by
Angelica Sirotin
CEO, Sirotin Ventures
Keep reading
More insights

/
AI at Work
Which Communications Tasks to Hand to Custom Agents and Which to Keep
Use custom agents for research, drafting and review without handing over the judgment, relationships and accountability that communications work requires.
Read article >

/
Strategic Communications
When a Fractional Communications Lead Beats an Agency or a Hire
When should you bring in a fractional communications lead? Consider the decisions, workload and support your business needs before choosing an agency or a hire.
Read article >

