How to Make Sustainability Claims That Hold Up in Due Diligence
GHG Protocol, SBTi and IFRS S2 each establish a different part of the evidence behind a climate claim. Here is how to write one investors can interrogate.

If a company says its emissions fell 20%, a reader still needs to know what was counted. The result could describe the whole value chain or a much smaller part of the business. It might reflect lower electricity use, a change in procurement or the sale of a factory that continues operating under somebody else’s ownership.
Those details belong in the explanation before the figure travels into an investor deck or a sales presentation. Once a broad headline is in circulation, the sustainability team may find itself repeatedly qualifying a claim it never intended to make.
We’d work through the accounting and target information with the people responsible before writing that headline. GHG Protocol, SBTi and IFRS S2 answer different questions, and understanding those differences helps a communications team explain the result without giving it more meaning than the evidence supports.
Establish what the emissions figure includes
GHG Protocol’s Corporate Standard provides a foundation for a corporate emissions inventory. A company defines its organizational boundary using equity share or a control approach, then accounts for the relevant emissions. That boundary affects the result, so it also affects the claim a writer can make from it.
The comparison year needs attention too. Significant acquisitions or divestments and changes in methodology can require base-year recalculation. If a factory has been sold, a smaller reported footprint may describe a change in ownership rather than a reduction in that factory’s emissions. The wording should help the reader understand which has happened.
For purchased electricity, distinguish location-based Scope 2 figures from market-based figures. The former use average emissions factors for the relevant grids; the latter reflect qualifying contractual instruments and supplier information. Under the Scope 2 Guidance, companies operating where those instruments are available report both. A lower market-based figure does not, by itself, show that electricity consumption fell.
Before approving the copy, we’d ask for the reporting period, boundary, scopes and calculation methods, together with an explanation of material changes or exclusions. If electricity procurement accounts for the improvement, say so. If the statement leaves out Scope 3 categories, readers should be able to see that limitation without finding it in a separate report.
The same discipline applies to comparisons with competitors. GHG Protocol’s Scope 3 Standard is designed to help a company track its emissions over time. Comparing companies requires further consistency in methods, data and performance measures; a lower disclosed total is not enough to establish sector leadership.
Separate the target from the progress toward it
SBTi Services assesses targets against the initiative’s standards and methodologies. When explaining a validated target, include the base and target years, the scopes and coverage, and whether the measure is absolute emissions or emissions intensity. An intensity measure relates emissions to a denominator such as output, so that ratio can improve while total emissions rise.
Interactive figure: intensity or absolute?
Validation also needs to be described within its limits. SBTi’s dashboard states that it does not assure the company will achieve the target or is currently on track. An investor update therefore needs the actual performance alongside the ambition, with an explanation of the reductions still required and the actions intended to achieve them.
Versions matter as standards change. SBTi has published Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0 and states that validation under it will open on February 1, 2027. Version 1.3.1 remains the submission route during 2026. A statement of alignment should name the applicable version and validation status rather than leave the reader to assume which requirements have been met.
Explain why the climate information matters to the business
IFRS S2 addresses climate-related risks and opportunities that could reasonably affect cash flows, access to finance or the cost of capital over different time horizons. Its requirements cover governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets, giving the reader a way to examine the financial implications.
For a manufacturer, that might involve electricity-price exposure, the cost of replacing equipment or the reliability of suppliers exposed to physical climate risks. The emissions inventory alone cannot answer those questions. A claim about improved margins needs the relevant financial and operating assumptions, while a claim about resilience needs an explanation of the risk and the response.
We’d keep those supporting arguments visible rather than allow a reduction in emissions to stand in for a broader business conclusion. We’d also confirm the applicable reporting requirements: an international standard is not automatically a legal obligation in every jurisdiction, and companies can apply ISSB standards voluntarily.
Show what the percentage means
Take a hypothetical manufacturer with a base-year inventory of 10,000 tonnes of CO2-equivalent. Scope 1 and market-based Scope 2 account for 2,000 tonnes, with Scope 3 accounting for the remaining 8,000. In the following year, the first subtotal falls to 1,600 tonnes and Scope 3 is unchanged. Assume consistent boundaries and methods, with no relevant exclusions or restatements.
The company has reduced its Scope 1 and market-based Scope 2 subtotal by 20%, but the total has fallen 4%, from 10,000 to 9,600 tonnes. Both calculations are correct. A headline that says only “emissions fell 20%” leaves out the boundary that makes the statement accurate.
Interactive figure: which 20%?
We’d explain it this way: “Scope 1 and market-based Scope 2 emissions fell 20% from the base year. Total reported emissions across Scopes 1, 2 and 3 fell 4% on the same accounting basis, while Scope 3 emissions were unchanged.” The next part of the explanation can describe the actions behind the result and point to the inventory. Any claim about progress toward a target must use that target’s actual boundary, while a claimed financial benefit needs its own analysis.
Keep the evidence close to the draft
A simple claim record gives sustainability, finance and communications something they can review together. Include the proposed wording and audience, the metric and comparison period, the methods and exclusions, and the relevant standard and target status. Keep the supporting document and accountable owner with it, including the scope of any independent assurance.
That preparation makes later changes easier. If a calculation is restated or a target renewed, the team can see which explanation needs updating instead of searching every presentation for a percentage that has lost its context.
At Sirotin Ventures, we work through technical material with the people responsible for it and help explain what investors and customers can reasonably conclude. If you’d like help reviewing the claims in your sustainability materials, email angelica@sirotinventures.com. We can start with the statements that receive the most attention and check whether the evidence is just as easy to find.

Written by
Angelica Sirotin
CEO, Sirotin Ventures
Keep reading
More insights

/
AI at Work
Which Communications Tasks to Hand to Custom Agents and Which to Keep
Use custom agents for research, drafting and review without handing over the judgment, relationships and accountability that communications work requires.
Read article >

/
Strategic Communications
When a Fractional Communications Lead Beats an Agency or a Hire
When should you bring in a fractional communications lead? Consider the decisions, workload and support your business needs before choosing an agency or a hire.
Read article >

